Collectibles
Step into OneStopWonders and you're surrounded by the holy grails. From graded trading cards and Funko Pop exclusives to comic books, wrestling belts, and one-of-a-kind memorabilia — every shelf is a treasure hunt. Whether you're chasing a specific chase variant, hunting for a sealed vintage box, or just want to browse aisles packed with collectible history, we built this place for collectors like you.
Graded Singles
PSA, BGS, CGC, SGC — our graded card cases are packed with the gems collectors dream about. Vintage Pokémon holos, modern sports rookies, Magic: The Gathering reserved list, Yu-Gi-Oh! ghost rares, and one-of-a-kind grails.
Hunting for a specific card? Bring your want-list — we'll dig through our singles binders and the cases to help you find it. We also buy and trade.
- Pokémon, Magic, Yu-Gi-Oh!, sports
- PSA, BGS, CGC, SGC slabs
- Buy, sell, & trade
Sports Cards & More
Football, baseball, basketball, hockey, soccer — our sports card cases run the full spectrum. Graded rookies, vintage legends, modern parallels, and sealed wax for breakers and collectors alike.
Beyond cards, we carry the holy grails of sports memorabilia — championship belts (yes, an authentic WCW Big Gold Belt is on the shelf), autographed pieces, and the kind of stuff you only see in a private collection.
- Vintage & modern sports rookies
- Wrestling belts & autographs
- Garbage Pail Kids & vintage oddballs
Funko Pop Headquarters
Hundreds of Funko Pop figures stacked into our signature display tower — commons, exclusives, chases, convention limiteds, and the legendary grails every collector is hunting for. From Marvel to DC, anime to Disney, Star Wars to WWE — if it's a Pop, we've got it.
New shipments land weekly and we carry exclusive and chase variants that you won't find in big-box stores. Hunting for a specific chase? Ask — we'll let you know when it lands.
- Hundreds of Pops in stock
- Chases, exclusives & vaulted
- New arrivals weekly
Aisle After Aisle
Comics, graphic novels, vinyl figures, soda cans, T-shirts, posters, retro toys, signed prints — the aisles of OneStopWonders are packed wall-to-wall with collectibles you won't find anywhere else in Waukesha.
Every visit is a treasure hunt. New stock arrives weekly, our team is plugged into the collector community, and we're always ready to dig through the back room to help you find that one piece you've been searching for.
See It in Person
Start Your Collection
Whether you're a serious collector, a casual fan, or shopping for the perfect gift — there's a treasure waiting for you. Stop in and explore.